For instance, when socrates declares in the apology that he could not. The philosophers of the art of living keep returning to platos socratic works because they contain both the most coherent and the least explicable model of a philosophical life that we possess. In angelas ashes by frank mccourt are there any literary devices like allusions, irony, parallelism, or symbolism. Irony is a communication technique employed when someone says something that conveys a message that contradicts the literal words. On the internet, i think the relevant term is trolling. Socratic irony, opting instead to take an objective stance. In this essay i account for the term socratic irony and i explain its meaning. On the concept of irony with continual reference to socrates danish. Part one is on socratic irony as exhibited by plato, xenophon, and aristophanes, with a closing section on hegel.
Whereas the aesthetic life emphasizes pleasure, the ethical life emphasizes an obligation. His letters seem to be a consideration of as aesthetic outlook and an ethical appeal to a. Aristotle takes a lenient view of such dissembling in the case of. The purpose of this article is to discriminate between the concepts of irony, satire, and parody. Socratic irony is a particular device often used in rhetoric in which one person pretends to be ignorant about an issue to lure the other person into explaining it. And now, its connected to the adobe document cloud. S ocratic irony and neuroscience the philosopher socrates lived from 469 to 399 b. It may well be said that at the centre of the debate about the very nature and function of socratic irony stands the late professor gregory vlastos book.
Adobe acrobat reader dc software is the free global standard for reliably viewing, printing, and commenting on pdf documents. Socratic irony is a technique used in the socratic method of teaching. Pdf socratic method in the euthyphro can be fruitfully analysed as a method. The quote could indicate that a is trying to hide his problematic thoughts and actions behind the pseudonym. Irony is a storytelling tool used to create a contrast between how things seem and how they really are beneath the surface. Kierkegaard, irony, and dualitya response to mark cortes favis article pdf available in the european legacy 174 july 2012 with 912 reads how we measure reads.
The concept of irony must be understood in terms of four distinct subtypes. For a number of reasons, this is an excellent time to prepare a new edition of the reader, and most of the changes will be incorporated into the next edition of readings in ancient greek philosophy. Situational irony is when something happens that is not expected. Socratic irony, platos apology, and kierkegaards on the. Socratic irony is conspicuous in the treatments of, for example, gregory vlastos, whose immediate concern is verbal irony, and alexander nehamas, whose interest is the irony of socrates situation and his attitude toward it. On the nature and function of socratic irony semantic scholar. Select stylistic devices, literary devices and figures of. He explains that verbal irony irony as it is traditionally understoodrefers to statements that mean something different frequently the opposite of what is literally intended, and defines sarcasm as a. Socrates then uses this irony to bring his interlocutors to a. Socratic irony is found in the dialogue of socrates only while platonic irony is found within the overall plot or message of the text. Plato employs dramatic irony to show that meno goes wrong in believing that. In view of the definition given, if socrates re marks are verbally ironic, then he is. If a firetruck catches fire, even though they are supposed to put it out. To argue using the socratic method, start by asking questions to make sure you understand what the other person is claiming, then ask for evidence to support their claims.
The reader who has watched socrates practise his negative method. But crucial for irony in the socratic dialogues is the dramatic context and the informed audience. Socratic irony refers to the practice of simulating ignorance in order to reveal the errors in another persons viewpoint or argument. The chapter reconsidering socratic irony by melissa lane in the. In romeo and juliet, the audience knows juliet is alive, but romeo thinks she is dead. Verbal irony occurs when a speaker deliberately highlights the literal falsity of his or her utterance, typically for the sake of hu mor. The best videos and questions to learn about literary devices. On the concept of irony with continual reference to. Socratic irony synonyms, socratic irony pronunciation, socratic irony translation, english dictionary definition of socratic irony. It passes intact into dr johnsons dictionary mode of speech in which the meaning is contrary to the words. Might a reader misunderstand satire if he interprets the authors satirical statement as literal, humorous. Project muse socratic perplexity and the nature of. For a book meant to be a popular introduction, it is remarkably comprehensiveeven end page 7 exhaustiveand serves to acquaint the reader with the current scholarly controversies surrounding socratic philosophy as it is debated in the analytic tradition associated most frequently with the late and great gregory vlastos. Socratic irony is one of the most important elements to platos many dialogues, and this is especially true in any reading of republic.
My focus is primarily on the aspects of irony that are directly valuable philosophically, although such a task also requires a discussion of its mere rhetorical forms. Pdf towards redefining socratic irony lunette warren. Socratic irony the classical quarterly cambridge core. Profession of ignorance and of willingness to learn, used as a ploy to spur others to discover their own ignorance through their attempts to explain a. Rather than a strict paradox, the term refers to either of two surprising and unacceptable conclusions drawn from the socratic dialogues of plato. Irony is the saying of one thing and meaning another. Socratic irony socratic irony is a technique used in the socratic method of teaching. This view resonates with ronells take on irony, but runs contrary to those who would either a valorize socrates as the progenitor or mouthpiece of earnest. Irony in the platonic dialogues stanford university. Hence we have at once an irony borne by a sophistic dialectic and a sophistic dialectic reposing in irony.
Cicero supplied a simpler and more helpful explanation. Socrates irony is so extreme that it soon ceases to be humorous. A work exhibits dramatic irony an irony which may be tragic or comic if the meaning of the speeches andor deeds of one or more of its characters is primarily visible to the reader or audience of the drama rather than to the characters in it. J kierkegaards socrates, the corsair affair, and the martyrdom of laughter filozofia 68, 20, no 1, p. To the reader, however, it seems apparent that socrates, even if he does not explicitly have the knowledge in question, is nevertheless in charge of the argument. Layne index readership all students and scholars interested in socrates, socratic dialogue and socratic literature, as well as the first thousand years of reception of the socratic circle. Socratic irony irony, say s quintilian, is that figure of speech or trope in which something contrary to what is said is to be understood contrarium ei quoddicitur intelligendum est. When someone draws out the other person, asking questions as if one is ignorant about the subject matter, then starts grilling the ot.
Socrates appears as an unwise fool seeking wisdom from the sophists only to draw them into a conversation and expose their true thoughts to. In the case of socratic irony, socrates might pretend to think his students wise or he might denigrate his own intelligence, as by pretending he. For lear, irony is fundamental to the human condition and a proper understanding of it can help us lead a distinctively human life p. Socratic irony, dramatic irony, irony of fate, and verbal irony. Kreuz describes eight different ways that irony has been used through the centuries, proceeding from socratic to dramatic to cosmic irony. We argue that satire and parody are literary genres, whereas irony is not. Aristotle defined irony as a dissembling toward the inner core of truth. What is socratic irony in simple terms and its example. The former is embodied in the thought of socrates that. A demonstration of justice through the personification of. In the phrase socratic irony, which, as here, is principally used with reference to platos character socrates, irony is also commonly understood to mean dissembling or disingenuousness. Yet, irony in the modern sense is evident in plato too, e. Socratic irony is so called because socrates adopted anothers point of view in order to reveal that persons weaknesses and eventually to ridicule him. Provide several specific examples where socratic irony is evident.
Select stylistic devices, literary devices and figures of speech urban 1 stylistic device tool or technique that offers extra meaning, idea or feeling literary device disruptive stylistic device forces reader to reconsider, reread and respond emotionally to what read. This thesis is the culmination of three years of extensive study on socrates, as seen from the view point of xenophon, aristophanes, and plato his thesis dealt with irony, and in. To the discussion of socratic irony it will add one aspect of irony that is often overlooked. This usage is clearly informed by the conventional understanding of eironeia, but irony does not mean deception. The three main types used in literature are dramatic, situational, and verbal, as mentioned above. A work exhibits dramatic irony an irony which may be tragic or comic if the meaning of the speeches andor deeds of one or more of its characters is primarily visible to the reader or audience of the drama rather than to. A presocratics reader began as a revised and expanded version of the first section of readings in ancient greek philosophy hackett, 1st edition 1995. Kierkegaard aligns himself with most critics when he asserts that xenophons socrates is unattractive and, more importantly, would not have been a man worth executing. The term comes from the latin word ironia, which means feigned ignorance. There is dramatic irony, situational irony, and verbal irony. Looking back at socrates and kierkegaards use of irony, lear hopes to recover this distinctively human aspect of our existence and incorporate it into our lives.
Although he is one of historys most famous philosophersarguably the most famoushe never wrote a word, unless we count a poem that he wrote in prison in athens while awaiting execution. Find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Next, challenge their assumptions by focusing on the ideas that arent supported by evidence. The standard form of the socratic dialogue, which the euthyphro follows, has socrates interrogating someone who claims to be an expert on a certain subjectin this case, holiness. Dramatic irony is when the reader knows something the character does not know. The greek eironeia false ignorance was first used by.
977 1285 273 871 1486 878 1211 82 1366 320 1009 217 1386 1198 1379 476 424 962 1562 6 1149 976 46 223 676 915 957 533 822 721 976 1200 1258 1362 1416 1553 1198 921 694 1364 1224 353 1331 1066 1190 1334 1061 1086 736